Search Results

JOIN! DEALS & REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) Why should I join/sign-up for My Crosby’s Rewards?​ My Crosby’s Rewards is a free and easy-to-use loyalty program that saves you money and rewards you for purchases at participating Crosby’s locations. My Crosby’s Rewards customers can earn points on valid purchases (restrictions apply) […]

Want a Crosby’s near you? Have you ever driven by a location and thought to yourself “Wow, would that be a good Crosby’s!”? Have you ever dreamt about having Crosby’s Pizza in your neighborhood and the perfect location just went on the market? We’d love to hear about it! Please use the form below to […]

Search Results

Welcome to Crosby’s Winner Wonderland! As of December 1st, every My Crosby’s Rewards (MCR) customer can partake in this game of daily adventures, prizes, and redemptions! Not a My Crosby’s Rewards member yet? Click Here to Get Registered! Details and rules of this exciting endeavor are as follows: To be eligible for the ‘prize/deal of […]

JOIN! DEALS & REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY POLICY T&C My Crosby’s Rewards Terms and Conditions Updated: August 2023 Void where prohibited by law. This promotion is intended for viewing and performance in the United States only and shall only be construed and evaluated according to United States law. Welcome to the My Crosby’s Rewards program, offered […]

Apply Now Career Opportunities Explore Our Benefits Awards & Engagement Careers At Crosby’s We Want You on Our Team! WE’RE HIRING NOW When you join the Crosby’s family, you’ll experience Team Spirit at our 88 stores throughout New York and Pennsylvania.  Every day, we work to provide enhanced Customer Focus in a setting with great […]

SMILE STORIES – Customer Comments With a Smile! Every day, both in our stores and online, we love to hear from our loyal and new customers. We hope your Crosby’s experience adds a smile to your day too! Your Crosby’s team members were very friendly and polite. The people are the best part of the […]

We Love Crosby’s! Our Associates Share the Love With a Smile! Team members throughout our Crosby’s stores love what they do for their fellow associates and for our customers. We hope your Crosby’s experience adds a smile to your day too! “Being able to bring a smile to a customer’s face not only adds a […]

Apply Now Career Opportunities Explore Our Benefits Awards & Engagement Awards and Engagement 100 Years in Business – 2022 – Family Owned for Four Generations Buffalo Niagara Business Ethics Award presented by the Business Ethics Association of Buffalo Niagara A WNY Healthiest Employer Risk Achievement of the Year (RAY) Award Recipient – Berkley Accident and […]

Apply Now Career Opportunities Explore Our Benefits Awards & Engagement Explore our Benefits Benefits – Rounding Out the Crosby’s Experience Working at Crosby’s you’ll have access to an amazing selection of benefits to assist in your career growth and personal well-being. Crosby’s associates become part of a culture where team spirit and customer focus are […]

Follow Us on Social Follow Crosby’s on our major social media platforms!  We’ll keep you updated on special offers, sales, and our community connections.  We also hope to hear from you.  Where is your favorite Crosby’s located?  Who’s your favorite associate?  What’s your go to pizza, sub or breakfast choice? Let us know! From our […]

Breakfast Sandwiches – Starting at $4.29Pizza Slices – $2.99Pizza Large – $19.99Pizza Sheet – $31.99 ORDER NOW! MAPLE CAKE SANDWICH Prepared to perfection egg, mild sausage patty, American cheese, between two maple hot cakes BREAKFAST SANDWICH Prepared to perfection egg with your choice of mild sausage, ham, or bacon; and American cheese; served on a […]

Subs & Sandwiches Half – $7.99 Whole – $11.99 ORDER NOW! TURKEY Fresh turkey topped with your choice of veggies, and choice of cheese HAM Fresh ham topped with your choice of veggies, and choice of cheese ITALIAN Fresh capicola, pepperoni, and salami topped with topped with your choice of veggies, and choice of cheese […]

Combo Meals ORDER NOW! LARGE CHEESE & 10 WINGS Our Original Cheese Pizza with 10 wings sauced your way $23.99 LARGE CHEESE & 20 WINGS Our Original Cheese Pizza with 20 wings sauced your way $35.99 SHEET CHEESE & 40 WINGS Our Original Cheese Pizza with 40 wings sauced your way $59.99 2 PIZZA SLICES […]

Sides ORDER NOW! CHICKEN BITES LIMITED TIME ONLY – Served with your choice of dipping sauce and a side of bleu cheese or ranch. 8oz box for $8.99, 16oz box for $16.99 CHICKEN WINGS Juicy plump wings available in multiples of 10 with your choice of sauce. 5 for $6.99, 10 for $12.99 CHICKEN TENDERS […]

Commitment to Community Crosby’s is so proud to have become an integral part of each community we serve.  From Western New York’s largest suburb to our hometown of Lockport, NY, to all of the many “ports,” “villages,” “towns,” “hamlets,” and “suburban” communities we are located in, Crosby’s continues to support the many community organizations that […]

We Love to Hear From You! If you have questions about our stores or are a My Crosby’s Rewards member who has feedback or needs assistance, please reach out to us. Tell Us What You ThinkPlease enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form. Name […]

Our Story With 88+ locations throughout New York and Pennsylvania, Crosby’s is the family owned and operated hometown choice for fresh pizza & subs, breakfast, on-the-go shopping, fuel & more! We can trace our roots back to 1922, with our organization being led more than a century later by 3rd and 4th generation members along with […]

Pizza Slices – 1 for $2.99, 2 for $5.39Large Cheese – $13.99Large Specialty – $19.99Sheet Cheese – $25.99Sheet Specialty – $34.99Pizza Toppings – Large $2.50, Sheet $4.50 ORDER NOW! ORIGINAL CHEESE Our signature dough topped with traditional marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese Add your favorite toppings for an additional fee VEGGIE Choice of traditional marinara […]

Calzones Slice – $4.99 Whole – $14.99 ORDER NOW! HAM & CHEESE Ham, mozzarella, and Swiss cheese SAUSAGE Sausage, peppers, onions, mozzarella cheese, and traditional marinara sauce MEATBALL Meatballs, mozzarella cheese, and traditional marinara sauce PEPPERONI Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, and traditional marinara sauce PHILLY CHEESESTEAK Red Osier roast beef sliced thin with green peppers, onions, […]

Apply Now Career Opportunities Explore Our Benefits Awards & Engagement Career Opportunities 01 Sales Associate 02 Shift Leader 03 Assistant Team Leader 04 Team Leader 05 District Leader Sales Associate Our Crosby’s associates are the lifeblood of the convenience store operation. An essential member of our customer service experience, the position of Sales Associate offers great […]

Food Menu Offerings ORDER NOW! Previous Next

JOIN! DEALS & REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Crosby’s Privacy Policy Updated: August 2023 Reid Stores, Inc. (“Crosby’s”) is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy. This Statement of Privacy (the “Policy”) applies to the Crosby’s Stores and My Crosby’s Rewards websites (the “Site” or “Sites”) and governs data collection and usage. This Policy explains […]

JOIN! DEALS & REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) Why should I join/sign-up for My Crosby’s Rewards?​ My Crosby’s Rewards is a free and easy-to-use loyalty program that saves you money and rewards you for purchases at participating Crosby’s locations. My Crosby’s Rewards customers can earn points on valid purchases (restrictions apply) […]

JOIN! DEALS & BENEFITS REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Rewards Intro Paragraph Subheading Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. How Can We Help?

JOIN! DEALS & BENEFITS REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Deals & Benefits Intro Paragraph Subheading Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. How Can We Help?

JOIN! DEALS & BENEFITS REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS Join My Crosby’s Rewards Intro Paragraph Subheading Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. How Can We Help?

JOIN! DEALS & REWARDS FAQs PRIVACY & TERMS My Crosby’s Rewards is designed to help you EARN and SAVE on your every day transactions, then redeem your earnings on FREE STUFF! We’ll even give you a FREE large cheese pizza on your birthday! JOIN TODAY SIGN IN With My Crosby’s Rewards you can automatically track your […]

Previous Next *My Crosby’s Rewards points will not be earned on purchases of alcohol, lottery or tobacco Great Deals View More Deals

85+ locations throughout New York and Pennsylvania Hometown choice for signature fresh pizzas, subs, breakfast, on-the-go shopping, and fuel.